Attributes and Assigning Them
As humans we tend to judge people or things by how we
believe them to be. It can’t be helped. This is part of our natural survival
mechanism. As pagans we are riddled with this. Somehow the belief that
everything must represent something else, uniformly, that it is true for
everyone across the board, has been adopted. How many times have you opened up a
book to tell you exactly what every color represents? How you should regard
every quarter? The list goes on and on. Attributes have been assigned to
EVERYTHING for us, and we tend to just take it and roll with it like it is
perfectly natural, but the key to this is, while assigning attributes to things
is natural for us on a very basic human level, following along what other
people tell us "is right" is not.
Huh?
Let’s say you REALLY like a shirt. Like, when you see it you get this image of you rocking it, turning heads when you walk down the street, owning the nightclub, feeling amazing about yourself and like you can conquer the world. This shirt is reasonably priced and it is yours…until, your best friend says she doesn’t like it and that this other shirt would do all that and more, a different shirt you don’t love. Do you fall in line with your friend or do you follow your gut?
I hope you follow your gut.
Now, I’m going to move this over to “our world”. I laugh every time I see “Use green to attract wealth, because green is the color of money.” and “Pine represents money, because it’s green.” Seriously? Really?
Fact. Most money in the world has no green in it.
Fact. Shells, especially those that are pale and shiny, were some of the first “currency” on the planet. Gems and crystals. Metals and minerals. Very few of these are green.
Why then should green, or something because it’s green, represent money based solely on that one single property? Why are we assigning that attribute when it doesn’t make historic, cultural or anthropological sense?
Would the Egyptians or ancients actually use a green candle and pine oil?
Hmmmm
Next, I was reading a book for kitchen witches which said that tart cherries should be used for alertness, awareness and wakening. When I looked deeper into this, the cherries were assigned this attribute because of their taste. As an herbalist this arbitrary nature made me laugh. Tart cherries contain the chemical melatonin, a sedative used especially by swing-shift workers to help them sleep naturally without side effects. Anyone using this “spell” would find themselves anything other than awake, alert and aware.
Here’s another, stop me if you know this one- you are joining in a ceremony. You’ve been handed a script to read when you call the corner. You simply don’t feel the wind candle should be yellow and the words don’t resonate with you but you do it anyway because this is what you’re told. I’m sure we’ve all found ourselves in this situation more than once. Now reflect on how effective that working was for you personally, deeply. If it doesn’t resonate within you, if you can not connect with it, it doesn’t work. Someone else assigned attributes to that area and it made you uncomfortable and discomfort does not good magic make.
I’m going to be bringing this up over and over but here is a bit of a revelation for you- we are the only religion that is supported by science.
Let me say this again: Biology, Astronomy, Physiology, Botany, Chemistry, etc… AND Archeology, Anthropology, Proven History all support our beliefs.
WOAH! How huge of a revelation is that?
We have countless studies to prove several of our beliefs, practices and holidays.
In addition to that, personal experience should be taken into account. For example (and this is another topic I will get into when I hit the “B’s”) I absolutely deplore that darkness/black is associated with bad and white is all things good. Fact of the matter is that science has shown black is ALL. It absorbs everything so it contains a little bit of each color we see. White is the absence of all, it reflects it all away. I, personally, am allergic to the sun. I am no fan of daylight at all and I find soothing comfort in the darkness. The idea of dark/black denoting evil is absolutely ridiculous to me when light hurts me so much.
I was looking through the same kitchen witch book from earlier that said to keep lavender for comfort, and while the chemical properties are proven to calm, for someone with asthma or allergies it is anything but soothing.
Huh?
Let’s say you REALLY like a shirt. Like, when you see it you get this image of you rocking it, turning heads when you walk down the street, owning the nightclub, feeling amazing about yourself and like you can conquer the world. This shirt is reasonably priced and it is yours…until, your best friend says she doesn’t like it and that this other shirt would do all that and more, a different shirt you don’t love. Do you fall in line with your friend or do you follow your gut?
I hope you follow your gut.
Now, I’m going to move this over to “our world”. I laugh every time I see “Use green to attract wealth, because green is the color of money.” and “Pine represents money, because it’s green.” Seriously? Really?
Fact. Most money in the world has no green in it.
Fact. Shells, especially those that are pale and shiny, were some of the first “currency” on the planet. Gems and crystals. Metals and minerals. Very few of these are green.
Why then should green, or something because it’s green, represent money based solely on that one single property? Why are we assigning that attribute when it doesn’t make historic, cultural or anthropological sense?
Would the Egyptians or ancients actually use a green candle and pine oil?
Hmmmm
Next, I was reading a book for kitchen witches which said that tart cherries should be used for alertness, awareness and wakening. When I looked deeper into this, the cherries were assigned this attribute because of their taste. As an herbalist this arbitrary nature made me laugh. Tart cherries contain the chemical melatonin, a sedative used especially by swing-shift workers to help them sleep naturally without side effects. Anyone using this “spell” would find themselves anything other than awake, alert and aware.
Here’s another, stop me if you know this one- you are joining in a ceremony. You’ve been handed a script to read when you call the corner. You simply don’t feel the wind candle should be yellow and the words don’t resonate with you but you do it anyway because this is what you’re told. I’m sure we’ve all found ourselves in this situation more than once. Now reflect on how effective that working was for you personally, deeply. If it doesn’t resonate within you, if you can not connect with it, it doesn’t work. Someone else assigned attributes to that area and it made you uncomfortable and discomfort does not good magic make.
I’m going to be bringing this up over and over but here is a bit of a revelation for you- we are the only religion that is supported by science.
Let me say this again: Biology, Astronomy, Physiology, Botany, Chemistry, etc… AND Archeology, Anthropology, Proven History all support our beliefs.
WOAH! How huge of a revelation is that?
We have countless studies to prove several of our beliefs, practices and holidays.
In addition to that, personal experience should be taken into account. For example (and this is another topic I will get into when I hit the “B’s”) I absolutely deplore that darkness/black is associated with bad and white is all things good. Fact of the matter is that science has shown black is ALL. It absorbs everything so it contains a little bit of each color we see. White is the absence of all, it reflects it all away. I, personally, am allergic to the sun. I am no fan of daylight at all and I find soothing comfort in the darkness. The idea of dark/black denoting evil is absolutely ridiculous to me when light hurts me so much.
I was looking through the same kitchen witch book from earlier that said to keep lavender for comfort, and while the chemical properties are proven to calm, for someone with asthma or allergies it is anything but soothing.
Just because someone in a book said something is so, does
not mean it is. Just because someone said “this is ancient wisdom” does not
mean it is (in all fairness, Wicca only came into being 70 years ago, not much
longer than Scientologists, and has been a mottled practice since then).
It’s so easy for us to go through the neo-pagan shelves at the bookstore and online and call that research, to rely on someone else doing the work for us, but in all honesty- is that truly YOUR practice? Is that you following your path or is it simply walking the path someone else laid down for you?
This, too, is ingrained in our society. Centuries of churches telling us how to believe, laws telling us how to behave, teachers telling us how to think, bosses telling us what to do…it just goes on and on. It’s become our comfort zone collectively as a society to drink down and eat up what others have written or tell us, whether or not it strikes a positive chord deep within us. This is where people end up moving from one thing to another, lost and not knowing who they are. It’s an epidemic in all facets of our society but I see it very much in the pagan community as people cycle from solitary to coven to open circle to group to solitary from one pantheon to another. They spend soooo much money on books, and then do spells from the books to bring money to them. I stand in awe and sadness when I see people desperately looking for a home, but I am also aware I can not give it to them.
It’s so easy for us to go through the neo-pagan shelves at the bookstore and online and call that research, to rely on someone else doing the work for us, but in all honesty- is that truly YOUR practice? Is that you following your path or is it simply walking the path someone else laid down for you?
This, too, is ingrained in our society. Centuries of churches telling us how to believe, laws telling us how to behave, teachers telling us how to think, bosses telling us what to do…it just goes on and on. It’s become our comfort zone collectively as a society to drink down and eat up what others have written or tell us, whether or not it strikes a positive chord deep within us. This is where people end up moving from one thing to another, lost and not knowing who they are. It’s an epidemic in all facets of our society but I see it very much in the pagan community as people cycle from solitary to coven to open circle to group to solitary from one pantheon to another. They spend soooo much money on books, and then do spells from the books to bring money to them. I stand in awe and sadness when I see people desperately looking for a home, but I am also aware I can not give it to them.
Why? Am I some cruel, heartless bitch that just stands by?
Perhaps sometimes, but rather than that I am a fan of the Socratic method of
learning. Socrates did not believe in giving people the information, he
believed in giving people the tools of finding the information and letting them
discover truths on their own. This, he said, helped people learn more and on a
much deeper level. This I whole heartedly believe. And with the internet at our
fingertips, it’s so much easier than ever.
Here’s my challenge to you. The next time you want to work some energy for protection, instead of opening a book and seeing what other people feel should be protective, close your eyes and feel it for yourself. What colors, scents, objects? Do some research outside of pagan specific books. Look to history, anthropology and science. If you have pagan books, skip to the bibliography and look for the more academic ones. Make it your own.
Here’s my challenge to you. The next time you want to work some energy for protection, instead of opening a book and seeing what other people feel should be protective, close your eyes and feel it for yourself. What colors, scents, objects? Do some research outside of pagan specific books. Look to history, anthropology and science. If you have pagan books, skip to the bibliography and look for the more academic ones. Make it your own.
If blue is angering, not soothing, then don’t use it to calm
you.
If you want to make a tea for healing, research the science and lore of the herbs yourself.
If you want to buy that shirt, then do it and wear it with pride!
If you want to make a tea for healing, research the science and lore of the herbs yourself.
If you want to buy that shirt, then do it and wear it with pride!
Always with kindess…blessed be.
I am with you all the way on this one. I think it's SO important to find out your own correspondences, as I mentioned in my 'A is for Air' blog post. I also think it's important to keep updating your correspondence lists from time to time, as what works at one time in your life may well change after a period. Excellent post! Thank you! :)
ReplyDeleteThank you, Sally. That is such a good point, to keep things updated. It is so true, as we (hopefully) evolve and grow our experiences will shape us even more and any attributes we assign may very well change.
DeleteI absolutely agree with you! Thank you!
Being that you are putting forth the concept of accuracy in attributions, I need to point out a mistake.
ReplyDeleteMelanin is a pigment employed to create a dark colour in skin and hair.
Melatonin is the hormone that aids sleep.
I'm quite liking the direction of your piece, I prefer when my correspondences make sense beyond the current modern fancy of the popular (read as sells books) neo-pagan publishings.
Thank you, Llyn. You are correct. I was typing so fast as I had my son waiting so we could go out on our "date night". I shall fix it. I did actually know that, I promise. ;)
ReplyDeleteBased upon the obvious effort you'd put into the piece, I figured as much. It's a simple enough error to make and I typo all the time, so no worries there, eh?
DeleteIt just tossed a bit of a mental spanner into what was otherwise a very well written and argued piece. I thought you would like the chance to correct it. ^_~
Love, love, LOVE this! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteI am so glad!! Thank you! :)
DeleteI agree with most of what you said here. Like you, I'm using correspondences that don't sit with what most books say (e.g. for me, Air isn't yellow, but blue, and Water is a violet shade).
ReplyDeleteHowever, I wonder what you mean when you say that the sciences support our beliefs. I can see that for example in herbal lore, science can proof which herbs are helpful for which ailment. But so far science hasn't proven any religion true (just because our ancestors did something, and their practices are attested by archaeology, doesn't mean that they were right in any way).
This is something I will be covering more in the future (in my "S's") but until then, Science hasn't looked at our religions but it has looked at the components of it over the years without realizing that's what it was doing.
DeleteHerbalism, yup.
Think about color and aromatherapy used- that has all been proven and backed by many, many scientific studies.
The Equinoxes and Solstices are not only proven to exist but are photographed from space. AND there are the egg experiments and such that can be done which show slight change that effects our physical world. The harvest calendar has changed so minimally.
Same thing with the pull of the moon. It's been proven that it does effect the world, especially water.
It's been proven that we can not exist without the 4 elements (the 5th I discuss in my next piece).
This isn't saying what we do with these things is proven, but if you look at other religions, most are based on suppositions without grounding, and their practices are either stolen or based on a day they align with a deity, when looked at from a scientific or anthropological place, the date was arbitrary. I could get into how other religions use science to achieve their religious mental states, but that's different.
We (Pagans) absolutely are supported by science more than any other religious group. I *never* said proven, btw. I said supported. There is a huge difference.
And as I said, many of the practices of neo-pagans (most especially Wiccans)are not those of ancestors but something created since it's inception in the 1950's based loosely on what was known *at that time*. The thing is, so much more has been discovered, uncovered, since then but with minimal changes to the practices set long ago. Which is why I am a huge fan of researching for ones self outside the realm of neo-pagan books.
Couldn't agree more, I always work with tools, ingredients etc that I feel are right for me and they may not work with another. I belonged to a group where sometimes I didn't feel comfortable with the chanting and banging of the drums or the clapping of the hands so I would shrink into the background, do it and feel a fool to myself needless to say shortly afterwards I left.
ReplyDeleteRachel x
I'm so sorry you went through that. I've worked with groups into the chanting and such as well and, I agree with you, it was simply not for me. I *truly* hope you've found something that works for you!
DeleteThank you so much for reading and sharing.
We see the flip side of this with Egyptian stuff. Especially when people get their ideas from movies.
ReplyDeleteThe associations the Egyptians had for jackals, for instance, were fast, graceful, and beautiful. People now get them mixed up with hyenas! That makes a world of difference for gods like Anubis and Wepwawet.
It's just like the green=money. People just go off a shallow correspondence without doing any research. Then they tell other people that their way is the only way.
Oh! A jackal confused with a hyena would cause some distress, absolutely.
DeleteYour statement about movies makes me think of the rush to do "light as a feather, stiff as a board" and dabble after the movie The Craft came out (I don't know if you are old enough to remember that, but I was young enough to see the surge in gothic witch tides who were all about it). Then of course there was the increase when Charmed became popular. You are so right about media involvement not helping people find their truth for themselves.
I agree with the "this is the only way" band wagon being so bad. All of the "major" neo-pagan authors write the whole green=money thing, as well as many other "truths". It's as if one put it down and everyone jumped on the wagon as it rolled by. Absolutely.
Thanks for taking the time to read and share!